国外用户对YAMAHYA CP5的评价以及和RD700NX的对比

田汉

Yamaha CP5 Reviews


"The following reviews are from owners of the Yamaha CP5. The most
recent review is at the bottom of this page", Graham Howard, Piano Advisor

1) "The keyboard action makes me happy every time I play"

I went on the internet and looked for some digital pianos and came across your guide. It shifted my focus on the Clavinova series. Based on looks I liked the CLP S 308PE. It has a modern appearance and as I understood the NW GH3 action.
However it is clearly not portable. So I still had some doubts.

I went to the biggest Yamaha shop in Bangkok where they have nearly the complete Yamaha program. So I spent hours and hours comparing pianos (including the acoustic U1 piano).
Some pianos like the modus series are very impressive but insanely expensive.

I still had the major conflict with portability so I tried the CP series as well and straight away I was positively impressed by the keyboard action of the CP1 and CP5 but not so much by CP50, CP155
However they do not have speakers inbuild so comparing was tricky.
So up to this point I was getting closer to buying the CLP S 308PE. 2 things made me hesitant: price and lack of portability.

Last Tuesday I decided to make a decision. I went back to the shop and this time I used headphones to check the CP1 an CP5. And I instantly knew that the CP5 is the answer to my dilemma. The keys feel very 'real' and the piano sounds are lightyears ahead of the P95. I dare to say that the electronics of the CP5 and the Clavinova are identical or similar. So the sound the pianos produce is ultimately defined by the speakers. I plan to use my hifi stereo system anyway at home so I decided not to trust the comparison between the sounds generated by the Clavinova's wooden body and a pair of headphones.

I sat down and made a list of factors that influence my ultimate decision. Here it is:
- portabilty -> CP5 wins
- sound -> similar when using a good stereo system with the CP5
- key action -> on paper the Clavinova wins as it has 'graded hammer action' which the CP5 does not have but the CP5s wooden weighted keys feel just great to me. I have tried real acoustic pianos (Heinrich, Yamaha) and there is a similarity there which is very pleasing.  So maybe it's a close call here between both pianos and as I said the Clavinova wins on paper.
- price -> the CP5 is expensive but so is the Clavinova (substantially more so).

In summary the CP5 won based on my view that the quality of both pianos is similar but the CP5 is cheaper and portable and so I bought it.

I have played it now for 5 days and here is my first review:

- portability needs some muscle but is fine
- sound with my 250W high end stereo system is stunning (Dynaudio/Symphonic Line) but I use it with a two channel 70W Marantz / Yamaha set which is still great.
- keyboard action makes me happy every time I play.

I have spent more time on the internet and found that most people prefer the Roland 700NX over the CP5 but this is professionals talking about marginal differences (I believe at least). There is talk about Yamaha using inferior electronic components in the stage pianos over the Clavinovas and about the inferiority of the S6 piano sound (can be tweaked) but I fully believe that this is a lost fight. It's a bit like comparing 24bit sampling of CDs over a traditional analog record.  The analog processing will always win and so will the acoustic piano.

I am confident that until the day I start looking for an acoustic piano I am happy with the CP5 - with all it is and with all it is not (an acoustic piano).

田汉

大致意思是说CP的手感和音色极好甚至超过自己的期望，每次演奏CP 5键盘和音色都会给人带来兴奋和愉悦的感觉，有很多专业人士推荐RD700NX，但我确信除非有一天我实在想买一台真的声学钢琴，否则我会一直喜欢我的CP5.

ChinaMoBro

Apple and orange.

三角架

Yamaha CP5 and the Roland RD-700NX Piano
by: Stomp

I've played the Yamaha CP5 live and I like it. My experiences says that Yamaha sounds much better in live settings, whereas for some strange reasons the Roland RD-700NX sounds much better only at home, when you hear it through headphones.

Though it is a personal choice, Roland has been experiencing key wear issues with their Ivory Feel keys. I am sure it could be a minor thing and Roland may be trying to fix it, I will go with the Yamaha CP5.