一个老外比较时下比较流行的舞台电钢琴

sylion

一个老外比较时下比较流行的舞台电钢琴：

Yesterday, I had some time to kill, so since I was in the area, I went to Rome's biggest music store and spent about an hour playing different digital pianos. I'd like to share some of my impressions - but keep in mind that I used the store's PA for listening, and sometimes the onboard speakers... hardly an objective listening environment.

Unfortunately, there was no RD700SX around, to confirm my recent playing impressions. But there was an RD700 *and* an RD300SX. So now I can confirm, with very little doubt, that the keybed on the RD700 is NOT the same one used by the RD700SX. The 700 keybed is more reminescent of the 300SX - that is, not in the same class of the 700SX.
I found the piano sounds on the 700 of rather high quality, but maybe not exactly on par with the SX models.

I played the Yamahas again: P250, P120, P90. By now, I am quite familiar with both sound and touch of those three pianos, and I like them all. The overall sound of the pianos is quite a bit brighter than the Rolands, and the keyboard (the same on all three) is very playable. Now that I've tried the RD700SX, I'd say that I prefer the Roland keboard over the Yamahas, but I still prefer the Yamaha keyboard over the RD300SX and RD700. Oh, and over almost *all* other digital pianos, except maybe the Kawai MP9000/95000.

I played all three models in the Casio Privia series (100, 200, 400), and I liked them even better than the last time. The piano sound is quite reminescent of the recent Rolands, just a bit less defined and open. The quality and resistance of the keyboard is really exceptional for the price, and the weight of just 12 kgs. is a real breakthrough in digital pianos. Don't plan to use the other sounds, however; EP1 is decent, but the others (EP2, strings, vibes, harpsichord) are mediocre, and the GM sounds are laughable.
But the piano sounds are good, with a good connection with the keyboard.
Overall, the best price/performance ratio in my opinion.

I also got to put my hands on a couple of Korgs, a Technics P50, a Yamaha P60, a GEM pre-ProMega model, a Roland RD170, and probably something else. Tell me I'm spoiled, but I didn't like any of those pianos. Most had poor piano sounds, inconsistent keyboard response, or both.

As usual: It's just my opinion!

sulv

YAMAHA P series are even better than those ones. .. and Casio Privia series are also as good as their price.

flystar

我的理解是,这个老外对yamaha的电钢更熟悉,但是他试用过roland rd700sx后,认为700sx keyboard比yamaha的好.另外,他认为除了Kawai MP9000/9500和yamaha的差不多外,rd300sx和rd700以及几乎其它所有的电钢都比不上yamaha.
这个老外认为yamaha的声音要比roland的更亮一点.
不能肯定,帖子里的keyboard是整个琴(声音和键盘)而言,还是仅指的琴的键盘.

wj95123

英文不好！看不懂啊！

cybergate

最后一段, 他说p60的键盘响应不一致, 声音很糟. 我觉得外国佬的话未必就很有参考价值, 还是自己试验的最好